Considering a move to New Windsor, NY? Situated in the scenic Hudson Valley, New Windsor offers a unique blend of quiet suburban life and convenient access to regional hubs, making it an increasingly popular choice for homebuyers.

Our advanced search pulls live data from the OneKey® MLS, the largest and most accurate listing service in the New York metro area. You'll find a variety of properties to suit your needs, from charming single-family homes and modern townhouses to spacious residential lots ready for your dream build. Each listing provides detailed photos, price history, and relevant local data to empower your decision-making process. Explore available homes in desirable neighborhoods like Vails Gate and Rock Tavern to find your perfect fit.

Homes For Sale in New Windsor NY

Listings are subject to the Fair Housing Act and OneKey® MLS rules.

Your New Windsor Real Estate Experts

The McGovern Caplicki Team brings more than 45 years of combined experience to New Windsor’s residential and commercial market. Because every team member lives and works in the Hudson Valley, you get on-the-ground insight into local schools, neighborhoods, and pricing trends. Skillful negotiation, targeted marketing, and clear communication guide each step, while our core values—family, integrity, and a bit of fun—shape the experience. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, we manage the details, keep you informed, and focus on results that move your life forward.

New Windsor Real Estate Market Insights

The New Windsor real estate market is dynamic, and understanding the latest trends gives buyers a competitive edge. Here are the most current statistics for the area:

  • Median Sale Price: $450,000 

  • Median Days on Market: 39 days

  • For-Sale Inventory: 145 homes 

  • Home Value Appreciation: +4.1% year-over-year 

New Windsor gives buyers a fair shot. Homes are moving in just over a month, prices are still inching up, and there’s a solid mix of listings to compare—so you can shop without rushing, yet still bank on steady value growth. Line up a strong pre-approval, keep an eye on fresh inventory each week, and you’ll have room to negotiate while the market works in your favor.

Living in New Windsor: Community & Lifestyle

New Windsor strikes a balance between small-town ease and Hudson Valley access. Just 60 miles north of New York City, the town sits at the junction of I-87 and I-84 and shares a runway with Stewart International Airport, keeping trips—whether by road, rail, or air—straightforward. Metro-North stations in nearby Salisbury Mills and Beacon link commuters directly to Manhattan.

Local employers such as St. Luke’s Cornwall Hospital and Garnet Health anchor a stable job base, while the broader Hudson Valley economy broadens career options. The result is a community that pairs everyday convenience with a laid-back pace—and a setting that lets residents enjoy both outdoor space and quick connections to larger hubs.

New Windsor Local Highlights & Attractions

Life in New Windsor is enriched by its beautiful parks, historical sites, and vibrant community events. There's always something to do in New Windsor or see.

  • Storm King Art Center: Explore this world-renowned 500-acre outdoor sculpture park, featuring large-scale installations by some of the most acclaimed artists of our time.

  • Hudson River Recreation: Enjoy scenic views and waterfront activities at Plum Point Park, a perfect spot for picnicking and relaxing by the river.

  • Historical Exploration: Step back in time at the New Windsor Cantonment and Knox's Headquarters State Historic Sites, which offer a glimpse into the area's significant Revolutionary War history.

  • National Purple Heart Hall of Honor: Pay tribute to the brave men and women who have been awarded the Purple Heart at this unique national institution.

  • Kristi Babcock Memorial Park: A hub for community life, this park hosts sports, contains playgrounds, and is the venue for the annual New Windsor Community Day.

  • Local Farms and Markets: Experience local flavor at places like Jones Farm and Overlook Farm Market, offering fresh produce, baked goods, and unique gifts.

  • New Windsor Community Day: An annual celebration held in September at Kristi Babcock Memorial Park, featuring rides, vendors, live music, and a fireworks show for the whole family.

New Windsor Area School Information

New Windsor is served by the New Windsor Central School District, which is known for its commitment to student success. The district includes several well-regarded schools. Additionally, some parts of the town are zoned for the respected Cornwall Central High School, offering more excellent educational choices. If you have particular school preferences, be sure to check the address with the district to see which school(s) you are eligible to attend.

Nearby higher education opportunities include Mount Saint Mary College in the adjacent city of Newburgh and the United States Military Academy at West Point, located just a short drive away.

Understanding New Windsor Crime & Safety

New Windsor is committed to maintaining a safe community for its residents. While crime statistics are a factor in any home buying decision, it's important to view them in context.

The New Windsor Police Department is highly engaged with the community, focusing on proactive policing and positive relationship-building. They run several community-focused programs, including a Community Policing Unit, Hope Not Handcuffs, and a drug collection initiative to enhance the quality of life. The department also promotes events like National Night Out to strengthen police-community partnerships.

How much are property taxes in New Windsor?

Plan on an effective rate of about 2.9 percent of your home’s assessed value. Bills arrive in late December and are due in January, but the exact amount depends on your property’s assessment and any exemptions you qualify for, such as STAR or senior relief.

What’s the commute like to New York City?

Driving runs roughly 1 hour 20 minutes, traffic willing. Prefer the train? Catch Metro-North at Salisbury Mills-Cornwall or Beacon: the Port Jervis Line reaches Penn Station via Secaucus, while the Hudson Line gets you to Grand Central in about 90 minutes.

What kinds of homes are common?

You’ll find everything from 19th-century farmhouses and mid-century ranches to newer colonials, plus a choice of town-house and condo developments. Vacant lots pop up, too, for buyers aiming to build from scratch.

Are there notable community events?

Yes—New Windsor Community Day each September packs Kristi Babcock Memorial Park with rides, food vendors, live music, and fireworks. The police department’s National Night Out in August also draws a big crowd and strengthens neighborhood ties.