By Brian Caplicki · Caplicki Home Team at Keller Williams Hudson Valley United · Updated October 28, 2026 · 5 min read
About $492,000. That was the typical sale price for a single-family house in New Windsor over the past year, about the same as the county-wide figure of $490,000, and a typical house reached signed contracts in about 41 days.
On this page: What does a home in New Windsor, NY cost right now? · Which New Windsor homes are for sale right now? · Which New Windsor school district is a house in? · Which part of New Windsor fits you? · How do you get to New York City from New Windsor? · What should you check on a New Windsor house before you make an offer? · If you are buying in New Windsor: what does your money get you? · If you are selling in New Windsor: how should you price? · How does New Windsor compare with nearby towns? · What is there to do in New Windsor? · What this page cannot tell you · More New Windsor guides from our team · New Windsor, NY real estate questions
What does a home in New Windsor, NY cost right now?
A typical New Windsor house sold for about $492,000 over the past year, up about 6 percent from the year before. More than 6 out of 10 sold at or above asking.
| Measure | New Windsor, past 12 months | The 12 months before |
|---|
| Typical sale price | $492,000 | $465,000 |
|---|
| Homes sold | 200 homes | 175 homes |
|---|
| Typical days to signed contracts | 41 days | 37 days |
|---|
| Sale price compared with asking | 100 percent of asking | 100 percent of asking |
|---|
Source: OneKey MLS, single-family homes in the Town of New Windsor, sold November 1, 2025 to October 28, 2026, compared with the 12 months before. Days run from listing to signed contracts and count only houses that sold. Condos and townhomes are not included.
We refresh the numbers on this page each quarter as new sales close. Last refreshed October 2026.
Which New Windsor homes are for sale right now?
Listings are subject to the Fair Housing Act and OneKey MLS rules.
Which New Windsor school district is a house in?
This is the question that matters most in New Windsor, and the listing sites get it wrong all the time. There is no single New Windsor school district. Four districts cover parts of the town:
- Newburgh Enlarged City School District
- Washingtonville Central School District
- Cornwall Central School District
- Valley Central School District
Houses a short drive apart can be in different districts, with different tax rates. Confirm the district by the exact address with the district office before you make an offer.
Which part of New Windsor fits you?
Vails Gate, just south of the City of Newburgh, is the busy crossroads with most of the shopping. Little Britain and Rock Tavern, out along Route 207 on the western side, are quieter and more rural. Beaver Dam Lake sits on the southern town line, and Firthcliffe Heights borders Cornwall.
A New Windsor house can carry a Newburgh, Vails Gate, Rock Tavern or Salisbury Mills mailing address. The town also has a good stock of condos and townhomes; see our New Windsor condos page.
How do you get to New York City from New Windsor?
New Windsor sits where the Thruway (I-87) meets I-84, and Stewart International Airport is partly in the town. Train riders cross the Newburgh-Beacon Bridge to Beacon on Metro-North's Hudson Line, or use Salisbury Mills-Cornwall station on the Port Jervis Line.
What should you check on a New Windsor house before you make an offer?
These are things we look at on almost every New Windsor house before a client writes an offer. None of it shows up on a listing site.
| What we check | Why it matters in New Windsor | What to do |
|---|
| School district | Four districts split the town, each with its own tax rate. | Confirm the district by exact address before you write an offer. |
|---|
| Mailing address vs. town | A Newburgh mailing address does not mean the City of Newburgh. | We confirm the town and tax bill from the tax map number. |
|---|
| Condos and townhomes | HOA fees and rules vary a lot by complex. | Get the HOA budget and rules before you commit. |
|---|
Where this comes from: the Caplicki Home Team's own experience on New Windsor sales, not data and not lender or legal guidance. Requirements vary by lender, loan type, town and year. Check with your own attorney, lender and inspector.
If you are buying in New Windsor: what does your money get you?
More house than in Goshen or Monroe. A typical single-family house sold for about $492,000, against about $542,500 in Monroe and $584,500 in Goshen, with quick highway access in every direction. Condos and townhomes come in lower.
More than 6 out of 10 houses sold at or above asking, so the good ones go fast. Get pre-approved before you tour. Run your numbers with the mortgage calculator and read our buyers guide.
If you are selling in New Windsor: how should you price?
Close to what similar houses sold for in your school district, not the town as a whole. Because four districts split the town, a town-wide average can be off for your street.
Our county studies on how to price a house to sell and how long it takes to sell apply here. Here is how we market a house once it is listed.
How does New Windsor compare with nearby towns?
New Windsor buyers often look at Cornwall and Washingtonville too. Town guides: Cornwall, Washingtonville, Montgomery, and the Orange County overview.
What is there to do in New Windsor?
Knox's Headquarters and the New Windsor Cantonment are Revolutionary War sites, and the National Purple Heart Hall of Honor is on Route 300. Plum Point park sits right on the Hudson. Storm King Art Center is a short drive away in Cornwall. Our full list is in things to do in New Windsor, NY.
What this page cannot tell you
These are a year of MLS sales of single-family houses for the whole town, across four school districts. The district, the condition and whether the house is a condo or a single-family home change the price of a specific house far more than the town figure does. For a number on your house, ask us.
More New Windsor guides from our team
Thinking about a move in New Windsor?
Selling: get a free estimate of what your house would sell for today, based on recent sales near you.
Get Free Home Value Estimate
Buying: call or text the team at 845-237-2368 and tell us what you are looking for. We will send new New Windsor listings the day they hit the market.
New Windsor, NY real estate questions
What is the typical home price in New Windsor, NY?
About $492,000 for a single-family house. That was the typical sale price in New Windsor over the past year, per OneKey MLS, up about 6 percent from the year before and about the same as the county-wide figure of $490,000.
Is there a New Windsor school district?
No. Four districts cover parts of the town: Newburgh Enlarged City, Washingtonville Central, Cornwall Central and Valley Central. Confirm the district by the exact address before you buy.
How fast are homes selling in New Windsor?
Over the past year a typical New Windsor house took about 41 days from listing to signed contracts, and more than 6 out of 10 sold at or above asking.
Is New Windsor the same as Newburgh?
No. New Windsor is its own town, next to the City and Town of Newburgh. Many New Windsor homes still carry a Newburgh mailing address, so check the tax map number.
Can you commute to New York City from New Windsor?
Yes. Drivers use the Thruway (I-87) and I-84, which meet at the town line. Train riders use Beacon on the Hudson Line or Salisbury Mills-Cornwall on the Port Jervis Line.
Are there condos and townhomes in New Windsor?
Yes, more than in most Orange County towns. HOA fees and rules vary by complex, so get the budget and rules before you commit. Our New Windsor condos page lists the main complexes.
What is New Windsor known for?
Revolutionary War history, including Knox's Headquarters and the New Windsor Cantonment, the National Purple Heart Hall of Honor, Plum Point on the Hudson, and Stewart International Airport.
The Caplicki Home Team is a Keller Williams Hudson Valley United real estate team based in Middletown, NY, serving Orange County, New York, and Sullivan County, New York. Helping local families buy and sell since 2000. Reach us at 845-237-2368 or brian@caplickihometeam.com.
