By Brian Caplicki, Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker · Caplicki Home Team at Keller Williams Hudson Valley United · Updated November 2026 · 7 min read
Yes. About 8.5 out of 10 Orange County houses listed in winter sold or went under contract, the same as spring. January and February listings that sold typically got their full first asking price in about 36 days.
|
New data · Updated November 2026 The short version: Yes, if you price it against what similar houses actually sold for. Winter listings here sold as often as spring ones, about 8.5 out of 10. January and February listings typically got full asking. Based on 5,236 Orange County single-family sales in OneKey MLS, closed November 2024 to November 2026, sorted by the month each house was first listed, plus OneKey MLS Quarterly Indicators. Put together by the Caplicki Home Team. |
Most people assume you wait for spring. Most years, most sellers do. That is exactly why winter can work.
Fewer houses come on the market from October through February. Buyers do not disappear. People still change jobs, get married, have babies and need to move before a school year. For prices and town guides across the county, see our Orange County, NY homes for sale page.
Here is what the last two winters actually looked like, in plain numbers.
How do houses listed in winter actually do in Orange County?
It depends which part of winter. We pulled 5,236 single-family houses that sold in Orange County over the last two years and sorted them by the month each one first came on the market.
Houses first listed in January and February typically sold at their full first asking price. They went under contract in about 36 days. Spring listings: full asking, about 34 days. There is almost no difference.
November and December listings took a few weeks longer over the holidays, about 56 days to a signed contract, and typically sold for about 98.3 percent of their first asking price. They sold just as often.
Orange County single-family houses that sold, by the months they were first listed
| First listed in | Houses that sold | Typical time to a signed contract | Typical sale price vs. first asking | Sold at or above first asking |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| November and December (2024, 2025) | 592 houses | 56 days | 98.3 percent | 4.2 out of 10 |
| January and February (2025, 2026) | 509 houses | 36 days | 100.0 percent | 5.3 out of 10 |
| March to May (2025, 2026) | 1,498 houses | 34 days | 100.0 percent | 5.5 out of 10 |
| June to August 2025 | 730 houses | 45 days | 99.0 percent | 4.8 out of 10 |
| September and October 2025 | 435 houses | 42 days | 99.2 percent | 4.8 out of 10 |
Source: OneKey MLS, Orange County, NY, single-family homes that closed between November 1, 2024 and November 16, 2026, pulled by the Caplicki Home Team on November 16, 2026. Each house is placed by the date it first came on the market, counted back from its signed contract using the MLS's cumulative days on market, so a house relisted under a new number keeps its original start date. Covers houses that sold only. Sale price against the original list price, before any seller concessions.
What about the houses that never sold?
Those count too, so we checked them. We took every single-family house listed in Orange County from November 2024 to October 2025, sold or not, and looked at where each one stood a year or more later.
Winter listings sold just as often. About 8.5 out of 10 of the January and February listings sold or went under contract, the same as spring and summer. November and December: 8.4 out of 10. About 1.4 to 1.5 out of 10 came off the market without selling, whatever the month.
Every Orange County single-family house listed November 2024 to October 2025: did it sell?
| First listed in | Houses listed | Sold or under contract | Came off the market unsold |
|---|---|---|---|
| November and December 2024 | 377 houses | 8.4 out of 10 | 1.5 out of 10 |
| January and February 2025 | 346 houses | 8.5 out of 10 | 1.4 out of 10 |
| March to May 2025 | 943 houses | 8.5 out of 10 | 1.4 out of 10 |
| June to August 2025 | 880 houses | 8.5 out of 10 | 1.4 out of 10 |
| September and October 2025 | 563 houses | 7.9 out of 10 | 1.5 out of 10 |
Source: OneKey MLS, Orange County, NY, single-family homes, pulled by the Caplicki Home Team on November 16, 2026. Includes sold, pending, active, temporarily off market, expired, canceled and withdrawn listings. A house that came off the market and later sold, or is listed again, is not counted as unsold. The rest of each row are houses still for sale. Status as of November 16, 2026, so every house here has had at least a year.
One more caution. November and December listings were a little less expensive, typically about $446,000 against about $490,000 in January and February, so they were not exactly the same kind of house.
How much less competition is there in an Orange County winter?
About a third less. From July to September 2025, 1,060 single-family houses came on the market in Orange County. From October to December 2025, 725 did. The year before showed the same drop.
Contracts fell far less. Buyers signed 697 contracts in July to September 2025 and 633 in October to December. That is about 1 in 10 fewer contracts, against about a third fewer new listings.
Put another way: in late fall, about 9 contracts were signed for every 10 new houses that came on the market. In spring 2026 it was about 5. That is the best ratio of the year, two years running.
Orange County single-family houses, by three-month stretch
| Months | New listings | Went under contract | Contracts per new listing | For sale at the end |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct to Dec 2024 | 691 houses | 597 houses | 8.6 for every 10 | 735 houses |
| Jan to Mar 2025 | 760 houses | 525 houses | 6.9 for every 10 | 722 houses |
| Apr to Jun 2025 | 1,175 houses | 666 houses | 5.7 for every 10 | 974 houses |
| Jul to Sep 2025 | 1,060 houses | 697 houses | 6.6 for every 10 | 1,038 houses |
| Oct to Dec 2025 | 725 houses | 633 houses | 8.7 for every 10 | 812 houses |
| Jan to Mar 2026 | 758 houses | 464 houses | 6.1 for every 10 | 808 houses |
| Apr to Jun 2026 | 1,454 houses | 737 houses | 5.1 for every 10 | 1,198 houses |
| Jul to Sep 2026 | 1,110 houses | 798 houses | 7.2 for every 10 | 1,114 houses |
Source: OneKey MLS Quarterly Indicators, Orange County, NY, single-family homes only, data as of October 7, 2026. "Went under contract" is OneKey's pending sales count. The houses that went under contract in a stretch are not the same houses that were listed in it; many were listed earlier. "For sale at the end" is the count on the last day of the stretch.
One caution on that table. The contracts in any stretch include houses listed earlier that finally sold. So the ratio shows how much buying there was against how many fresh houses arrived. It is not the share of new listings that sold.
Why do winter sales look worse in most market reports?
Because most market reports sort houses by the month they closed, not the month they were listed. And many of the houses that close in winter have been for sale since summer or fall.
Of the 502 Orange County single-family houses that closed from January to March 2026, 325 were first listed before November. That is about 6 in 10. About 3 in 10 had been listed before September. The year before looked the same: 342 of 550.
Those older listings typically took about 84 days to get to a signed contract and sold for about 96.2 percent of their first asking price. Mixed in with the fresh winter listings, they drag the winter average down. Sort by listing month instead and January and February look like spring.
If you are selling: how do you make a winter listing work?
Price it against what houses your size in your school district actually sold for. Not against what the neighbors are asking. That matters more in winter, because the buyers who are out are serious and they have seen everything on the market. Here is how to price your house to sell.
List when you are ready. A November or December listing sold as often as any other month; give it a few extra weeks over the holidays. January and February listings moved about as fast as spring ones.
This year there may be an extra reason to list before spring. The Federal Reserve meets on December 9, and as of November 12, betting markets put the odds of a rate increase at about 87 percent for a quarter point. The Fed's rate is not a mortgage rate, but buyers worried about higher rates are trying to lock in before the end of the year. That can make late fall and early winter an even better window for a well-priced house than the numbers above show.
Count back from your move. In New York the attorneys draw the contract after the inspection, so the signed contract comes about three weeks after the handshake. Closing usually runs another two to three months after that. List in January and you are likely closing in spring.
Make the house easy to see. It is dark before 5 o'clock in December. Clear the walk and the driveway, keep every light on for showings, and keep the heat up even if you have moved out. We put every listing in front of buyers the same way all year; here is how we market your home.
And check your town. Some Orange County towns sell best in late winter, others in summer. Our town-by-town guide to the best time to sell shows which month peaks where you live.
If you are buying: is winter a better time to negotiate?
On the right houses, yes. The houses that sat since summer or fall and closed from January to March 2026 sold for about 96.2 percent of their first asking price.
Fresh January and February listings are a different story. They typically sold at full asking, about as fast as in spring. So ask when a house first came on the market, not just how long the current listing has been up, and whether the price has already come down.
The trade-off is choice. There were 812 single-family houses for sale in Orange County at the end of December 2025, against 1,038 at the end of September. Going into this winter there are more than last year: 1,114 at the end of September 2026.
Mortgage rates matter too. The 30-year fixed averaged about 7.11 percent in the week of November 12, 2026, up from about 6.24 percent a year earlier, according to Freddie Mac. With a Fed rate increase widely expected in December, waiting for spring may not mean a lower rate. If you are ready, getting a rate locked before then is worth talking to your lender about. And if you close in January, the town and county tax bill arrives right around then. Your attorney splits it with the seller by the day. Here is what that bill looks like in each town: Orange County property taxes by town.
The bottom line
Winter is not the dead season people think it is in Orange County, NY. Fewer houses come on the market and buyers keep signing. A well-priced winter listing sold about as often as a spring one, and January and February listings typically got full asking.
If your move does not fit a spring calendar, you do not need to wait for one.
Thinking about listing this winter, or buying before spring?
Selling: get a free, instant estimate of what your Orange County home is worth today. No phone call required, no obligation.
Get My Free Home Value Estimate
Buying: call the team at 845-237-2368 and we will tell you which houses have room to negotiate.
Selling or buying in an Orange County winter: FAQ
Is it a bad idea to sell a house in winter in Orange County, NY?
No. About 8.5 out of 10 Orange County houses listed in January and February 2025 sold or went under contract, the same as spring listings. The ones that sold typically got their full first asking price and went under contract in about 36 days, against about 34 for spring. November and December listings sold just as often and took a few weeks longer.
How long does it take to sell a house in winter in Orange County, NY?
For a house listed in January or February, plan on about five weeks to a signed contract, then about two to three months to closing. A November or December listing typically took about 56 days, so allow a few extra weeks over the holidays.
Do houses sell for less in winter in Orange County, NY?
Not if they are listed in January or February. Those houses typically sold at their full first asking price, the same as spring listings. Winter sales look lower in most reports because about 6 in 10 of the houses that close from January to March were first listed before November, and many had already cut their price.
Should I wait until spring to list my house in Orange County, NY?
If your house is ready, a January or February listing did about as well as a spring one over the last two years, with less competition. In April to June 2026, 1,454 new single-family listings came on the market in Orange County, about twice as many as in January to March. Our town-by-town guide shows which towns peak in which month.
If I close in January, who pays the Orange County town and county tax bill?
Both sides pay their share. Town and county bills go out at the end of December. In New Windsor, for example, they are due without penalty through January. At closing, the attorneys split that bill by the day, so the seller pays for the days they owned the house and the buyer pays for the rest.
Is winter a good time to buy a house in Orange County, NY?
It can be, if you look at the right houses. Orange County houses that closed in January to March 2026 after being listed before November sold for about 96.2 percent of their first asking price, after about 84 days. Fresh January and February listings rarely gave that room. Mortgage rates were about 7.11 percent for a 30-year fixed in the week of November 12, 2026, per Freddie Mac.
The Caplicki Home Team is a Keller Williams Hudson Valley United real estate team based in Middletown, NY, serving Orange County, New York, and Sullivan County, New York. Helping local families buy and sell since 2000. Reach us at 845-237-2368 or brian@caplickihometeam.com.